5 Best Similar Benefit Cookie Highlighter Products

Best Similar Benefit Cookie Highlighter Products

If you can find the almost same result in less expensive and easily available highlighters from decent brands, what is the need to splurge on pricey products?

There is no doubt that Benefit Cookie Highlighter is one of the best in the market, but something that does not attract people is its high price. In fact, all the makeup products from Benefit Cookie are iconic- be it powder blushes, bronzers, eyebrow lines, and any other. Likewise, the highlighter is stunning in all ways. But, the only downside is the price.

Therefore, we have hand-picked some ultimate Benefit Cookie Highlighter alterniatives that will fit your beauty budget and gives the best result.

Top PicksCheck Price
KYDA Face Highlighter Palette KitBuy on Amazon
Fabulure Highlighter Powder PaletteBuy on Amazon
Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Highlighter PearlBuy on Amazon
ELLESY Highlighter Makeup PaletteBuy on Amazon
Wet n Wild MegaGlo Highlighting PowderBuy on Amazon

Before checking them, let’s find out a few things more about Benefit Cookie Highlighter that makes it so special and popular.
Similar Benefit Cookie Highlighter

Buy On Amazon


Benefit Cookie Highlighter is a silky fine highlighter that delivers a gorgeous glow with just one swipe. It is a powder highlighter with soft gold shimmer and superfine buildable features. If you want to get freshly baked cheeks that look gorgeous with soft gold shimmer for a warm, delicious glow, nothing will work better than Benefit Cookie Highlighter.

It is a binding formula and comes with a golden pearl shade. This stunning shade of Benefit Cookie Highlighter is extremely flattering and goes well with light to medium skin tones.

The formula is pigmented and intense with no chunky glitter particles. It looks smooth and vibrant on the skin. Coming in Benefit’s Cookie signature classic cardboard box, the design and quality are excellent.

The major components of Benefit Cookie Highlighter include dimethicone, mica, alumina, isododecane, polyglyceryl-2 triisostearate, triethylhexanoin, polyethylene, magnesium myristate, phenoxyethanol, caprylyl glycol, peg-12 dimethicone, tin oxide.

Even though everything about Benefit Cookie Highlighter is nice, the price seems high. Therefore, looking for Benefit Cookie Highlighter alternatives is justified.

A good alterniative that can replace Benefit Cookie Highlighter should be-

  • Without glitter particles
  • Soft powdery formula which is buttery and easy to use
  • Warm tones shade
  • Intensely pigmented


Smooth and easily buildable
High-quality, infused with skin-friendly components
Perfect for light and medium skin tones


  • Highly-priced
  • A lot of alternatives are available at a reasonable price

5 Benefit Cookie Highlighter Alternatives

1. KYDA Face Highlighter Palette Kit

KYDA Face Highlighter Palette Kit

Buy On Amazon

If Benefit Cookie Highlighter seems pricy and out of league, highlighter palette kit from KYDA could be a great pick.

  • It is an amazing highlighter concealer palette with shimmering powder that immediately gives the face a three-dimensional display.
  • The smooth delicate and silky glitter powder that spread smoothly on the face to have a non-marking, powder-free, smooth highlight makeup.
  • Comes with a professional brush; therefore, easy to apply.
  • Available in 3 colors wherein beige gold fits the skin tone best; nude powder does not show pores.

2. Fabulure Highlighter Powder Palette

Fabulure Highlighter Powder Palette

Buy On Amazon

It is another good option to splurge into as it delivers similar result and comes at an affordable price.

  • It suits all skin tone, and ideal for brightening cheekbones, eyelids, brow bones, inner corners and lip.
  • It creates a natural shimmer to the skin.
  • With super silky soft texture, it naturally helps achieve seamless coverage.
  • It is a waterproof and enlighten palatte that comes with 4 highlighters to create the perfect glow.
  • It is a long-lasting highlighter which is waterproof and smudge-proof.

3. Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Highlighter Pearl

Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Highlighter Pearl

Buy On Amazon

It could be one of the best choices if Benefit Cookie Highlighter outweighs your beauty budget.

  • It is a gorgeous makeup highlighter to strobe, or sculpt with contour, over foundation makeup or worn alone.
  • With a cream-to-powder finish and ultra-refined, soft focus pigment, it is a perfect similar for Benefit Cookie Highlighter.
  • Infused with Murumuru Butter, Cupuaçu Butter, and Tucuma Butter from the lush, nutrient-rich Amazon.
  • Suitable for all types of skin, including sensitive skin.

4. ELLESY Highlighter Makeup Palette

ELLESY Highlighter Makeup Palette

Buy On Amazon

For all the good reasons, ELLESY Highlighter Makeup Palette has been a perfect similar for Benefit Cookie Highlighter.
It is a waterproof and long-lasting highlighter palette consisting of shimmer highlighter powder that suits all skin tones.

  • Comes in 4 different shades wherein light gold and polarized pink purple suits all.
  • The soft texture ensures long-lasting makeup.
  • Excellent and no pores formula, which is natural and not ostentatious, help to create a three-dimensional makeup.
  • It is vegan-friendly and never tested on animals.

5. Wet n Wild MegaGlo Highlighting Powder

Wet n Wild MegaGlo Highlighting Powder

Buy On Amazon

  • Buttery, buildable formula melts onto the skin for a weightless feel & effortlessly blended application.
  • Formulated with micro-fine pearls, this highlighter creates a multi-dimensional, light-catching effect.
  • Infused with skin-loving ingredients like Vitamin E, Murumuru Seed Butter, Shea Butter & Argan Oil that work to nourish the skin and helps you achieve a luminous glow.
  • 100% cruelty free and vegan formulation.

You Might Also Like:

Was this article helpful?